From our family kitchen to your table — every dish is handcrafted with authentic recipes, fresh ingredients, and the kind of warmth that makes you want to come back.
Cotija Mexican Restaurant was born from a simple belief: the best food comes from real ingredients, honest preparation, and a love of feeding people well. Located right here in Sheridan, we've built a space where every bite feels like home cooking at its finest.
Traditional flavors passed down through generations, prepared the way they should be.
We source locally and prepare everything from scratch so every plate arrives at peak flavor.
We're proud to be part of Sheridan's dining scene — your neighbors cooking for your neighbors.
It's not just about what's on the plate — it's about the whole experience.
Relaxed, colorful atmosphere perfect for a casual lunch or a family dinner. Great food tastes even better in good company.
Call ahead and grab your favorites on the way home. Hot, fresh, and ready when you are — no fuss, no wait.
Hosting a gathering? We welcome groups of all sizes with generous portions and a menu that satisfies everyone at the table.
Every dish is prepared with attention to detail and genuine care — because good food isn't just made, it's made with heart.
Don't just take our word for it — hear from the people who make Cotija their regular spot.
Best Mexican food in Sheridan, hands down. The tacos are always fresh and the salsa bar is incredible. We come here at least once a week now.
The burrito I got was massive — honestly one of the best I've had anywhere. Friendly staff, quick service, and the prices are really fair for how much food you get.
Finally a real Mexican restaurant in the area! The enchiladas taste just like my abuela used to make. The atmosphere is warm and inviting — feels like home.
Whether you're dining in, picking up, or feeding the whole crew — we've got something delicious waiting for you at Cotija.
Located in the heart of Sheridan
Call for takeout or questions
11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
622 S Rock St
Sheridan, AR 72150
Monday – Sunday
11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
